I developed this recipe for what I am calling a Crostata Stellata, for a Ci Piace Cucinare Christmas menu. It all started after our summer trip to Abruzzo, when I started researching traditional sweets for a Lunch in Abruzzo story. I stumbled across a recipe for Sfogliatelle Abruzzese, a kind of cousin of Neopolitan sfogliatelle, perhaps one of the greatest sweets ever created, on par with Baclava, Tarte Tatin and the strawberry cream puffs my Grandma loved from Patterson’s Cake Shop.

The Sfogliatelle Abruzzese were a revelation, partly because the pasta riccia was much easier than expected, and partly because the traditional filling of grape jam mixed with chopped nuts, and enriched with a choice of candied citrus, dark chocolate and/or spices reminded me of mince pie filling. Grape jam, a bit fiddly if you pick the seeded grapes from the garden pergola, but totally delicious and a fresh version of soaked and cooked sultanas, being the same thing really, just via different routes.

When Ci Piace asked for a Christmas menu I did try to get actual mince tarts in (along with a double cooked and glazed Gammon) but they weren’t chosen, a shame because English Christmas dishes really are the arena in which we Anglo Saxons can stand an inch taller and tell the Italians just how wonderful roast turkey with two different stuffings, gravy, a medley of roast vegetables, various sauces and then plum pudding with more sauces and perhaps a scoop of rich vanilla icecream really is.

The result being that I presented a very Italian looking crostata, with a very Italian filling, a version of the aforementioned grape composto from Abruzzo, but that with its heady fruitiness and wafts of spices tastes almost exactly like a mince pie, minus the suet if you want to be finicky. (I freely admit to having never made mincemeat, which you can read about here along with a super recipe for mince pie pastry with lard.)

If you don’t have fresh grapes to hand – in Italy it is normal to find them in the markets until December – substitute with a large jar of grape jam or sultanas soaked in tepid water or white wine. I like making shortcrust pastry with a mix of flours but straight plain flour works too.

Crostata Stellata

For a tart tin of roughly 22 cm

150 g plain flour (farina 00)
150 g fine ground semola flour (farina di semola rimacinata)
100 g icing sugar
1 pinch salt
Zest of half an untreated orange (or lemon)
150 g butter – cold and cubed
2 small-medium eggs

900 g unseeded grapes – can be any colour – and if they have seeds split and deseed first
3 small pears
300 g sugar
100 g brown sugar
80-100 g hazelnuts and/or walnuts
60 g candied orange
Juice of a small lemon
1/4 teaspoon of ground cinammon
1/4 teaspoon of ground cloves

The pastry can be made by hand or stand mixer or food processor. It can also be made in advance and keeps well for a couple of days in the fridge and can be frozen for up to 3 months.

Mix all of the dry ingredients and citrus zest together, then add the chilled butter cut into small pieces. Rub the butter into the flour using the tips of your fingers and once mixture has the consistency of breadcrumbs add two smallish eggs, beaten, and mix well until the mixture comes together in a ball. If the pastry is still dry add a teaspoon of water.

Turn out onto a well floured surface, knead until it has a uniform consistency, and cut into two almost halves, with one half slightly larger, which will be for the base. Form each into a disk shaped piece, cover with baking paper or plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least an hour before using.

The grape jam is a somewhat lengthy process so this could be done a day, or even days, before. Wash the grapes well, remove from stalks, and put into a large saucepan and cook over a low heat for 40 to 60 minutes, bashing with a wooden spoon once every so often so that the grapes burst and start to collapse. Peel and chop the pears, eliminating cores and adding to the mix about half way though. How long it takes to get to the stage when the fruit is soft and mushy will depend on the fruit so keep an eye on things.

Once the fruit is soft, drain off a couple of tablespoons of liquid, add the sugar and lemon juice and cook over a menium heat for another 25-30 minutes until the jam is dense and sticky. Allow it to cool a little before folding in the chopped nuts, spices and finely diced citrus peel.

Preheat the oven to 180°C.

On a clean and lightly floured surface roll out the larger piece of the chilled pastry and fit into a tart tin with a removable base. Press into the tin well, trim the edges using the back side of a fine butter knife and prick the base with a fork. Fill the tart with the sticky, scented filling and roll out the top piece. Use a stencil or a giant star cutter (which I didn’t have) to cut a star from the top and position over the base, which has been brushed with a little water to help bind the two pieces. Trim the edges by pressing in to the tin, and crimp with the back of a fork.

I baked mine for 50 minutes in a fan forced 180°C oven. Dust with icing sugar while still slightly warm so that it melts into the jam mixture.


7 replies
  1. Georgie Tipper
    Georgie Tipper says:

    Thank you Alice, this looks delicious. I hadn’t thought of using grapes as a filling before but I am looking forward to trying this. Hope all is well with you and yours.

    • alicekiandra70
      alicekiandra70 says:

      Hello Georgie! We are all fine, ready to hunker down and do a lot of cooking and eating I guess. Sending a huge bacio over the channel to you and David. It is amazing (and also not) how much the grapes end up tasting like sultanas.

  2. Ruth
    Ruth says:

    Ooh this looks excellent. Miss mince pies so much here in Italy, and was about to consider making my own, but this looks interesting!! Any thoughts on how to use a pre-made (homemade) grape jam rather than starting from scratch? My husbands zia makes a fantastic grape jam (she’s got the time and patience for de-seeding!) and I’ve got a few jars of it scurried away.

    • Alice Adams Carosi
      Alice Adams Carosi says:

      Ruth, so sorry I missed this comment, and Christmas is now behind us. Yes! Absolutely you can use pre-made grape jam, actually half the effort saved just like that. Let me know if you make it, I guess we can still eat mince pies for a while. Buon 2021, Alice


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.